BlackLeafwatch the watchmen
Mine Safety

Coal is expanding. The agency that inspects it is not.

Summary

MSHA's appropriation has been frozen at exactly $387,816,000 for four straight fiscal years. Its enforcement staff has fallen 23% since 2017, to 1,656 people, while the White House pushes coal production up.

By Nero · July 9, 2026

The Mine Safety and Health Administration exists for one statutory reason: inspect every underground mine four times a year, every surface mine twice, and write it up. It answers to a law from 1977, not to the market. But its budget and its production mandate are moving in opposite directions at the same time. MSHA's own FY2026 budget request opens by citing the executive orders driving that mandate directly — "Reinvigorating America's Beautiful Clean Coal Industry" and "Declaring a National Energy Emergency" among them. Nearly 330,000 people work at more than 12,600 mines nationwide, per that same document. The agency watching over them has been shrinking for a decade.

MSHA's FY2025 budget
$387.8M
unchanged since FY2023
Enforcement staff
1,656
−23% since FY2017 vs 2,152 in FY2017
Inspection hours per mine
41
−15% since FY2019 vs 48 in FY2019

Where the mine safety dollar goes

Congress funds MSHA in seven activity lines. Almost seven of every ten dollars pay for one of them: the inspectors themselves. The chart groups the three smallest lines into "Other"; the table below it lists all seven individually.

MSHA's FY2025 budget, by activity
Enacted budget authority, fiscal year 2025, $ millions
MSHA FY2025 appropriation$387.8MMine Safety & Health Enforcement$266.5MEducational Policy & Development$39.1MTechnical Support$36MProgram Administration$16.9MOther MSHA offices$29.3M
Source: U.S. Department of Labor, FY2026 Congressional Budget Justification, MSHA volume (Summary Budget Authority and FTE by Activity, p. MSHA-5)
View data as table
MSHA FY2025 enacted budget authority, all seven activity lines
Mine Safety & Health Enforcement$266.5M1,231 FTE
Educational Policy & Development$39.1M102 FTE
Technical Support$36.0M161 FTE
Program Administration$16.9M70 FTE
Program Evaluation & Info. Resources$16.1M19 FTE
Office of Assessments$8.2M38 FTE
Standards, Regulations & Variances$5.0M16 FTE

Of the $387,816,000 Congress enacted for fiscal 2025, per the FY2026 Congressional Budget Justification, $266.5 million — 68.7% of the total, staffed by 1,231 of the agency's 1,637 enacted positions — funds "Mine Safety and Health Enforcement," the line that pays inspectors to go underground. The rest funds training, technical labs, penalty assessment, and the agency's own back office. That figure hasn't moved: FY2023, FY2024, and FY2025 were each appropriated exactly $387,816,000, and reporting on the enacted FY2026 Labor-HHS omnibus puts this year at the same number — Congress rejected the administration's proposed 10% cut to $348,207,000 for a second year running.

The inspectors have not kept pace

A flat dollar total isn't a flat agency. MSHA's authorized workforce has been sliding since well before this budget freeze began.

MSHA authorized staffing, FY2017–FY2026
Full-time equivalent positions, by fiscal year
FY 2017
2,152
FY 2019
1,984
FY 2021
1,707
FY 2023
1,747
FY 2025
1,656
FY 2026 (request)
1,590
Source: U.S. Department of Labor, FY2026 Congressional Budget Justification, MSHA volume (Appropriation History, p. MSHA-8)
View data as table
MSHA appropriated FTE and dollar total by fiscal year
FY 20172,152 FTE$373,816,000 appropriated
FY 20191,984 FTE$373,816,000 appropriated
FY 20211,707 FTE$379,816,000 appropriated
FY 20231,747 FTE$387,816,000 appropriated
FY 20251,656 FTE$387,816,000 appropriated
FY 2026 (request)1,590 FTE$348,207,000 requested — rejected; Congress held FY2026 flat with FY2025

In FY2017, per the same Congressional Budget Justification, MSHA was funded for 2,152 positions. By FY2025 that had fallen to 1,656 — a 23% drop — even as the appropriated dollar total rose slightly, from $373.8 million to $387.8 million. The administration's FY2026 request would have cut both further, to $348.2 million and 1,590 ; Congress restored the dollars but left the staffing trajectory unaddressed. Attrition is the mechanism, not layoffs — the agency's own budget documents note that a newly hired enforcement inspector needs about two years of classroom and on-the-job training before independently inspecting a mine, so every departure takes years to backfill.

That thinning shows up on the ground. Bloomberg Law reported that more than 30 MSHA field-office leases were slated for termination in 2025; most were reversed after pushback from coal-state lawmakers, but four offices — including the Pineville, West Virginia and Mount Pleasant, Pennsylvania district offices — remained slated for closure as of that reporting, with Bloomberg Law's analysis finding the Beckley, West Virginia district would absorb a more than 80% increase in oversight responsibility if merged with Pineville's caseload.

Inspection hours, and what they bought

Fewer inspectors funded the same way inevitably means less time in each mine. The clearest measure of that is total inspection hours per mine per year — and it has not returned to its 2019 level since.

Inspection hours per mine, FY2019–FY2025
Total mining-area inspection hours per mine, all mines, by fiscal year
FY 2019
48
FY 2020
42
FY 2021
39
FY 2022
40
FY 2023
41
FY 2024
42
FY 2025
41
Source: MSHA, Mine Safety and Health At a Glance, fiscal-year edition (issued Feb. 27, 2026)
View data as table
Inspection hours per mine and fatalities by fiscal year
FY 201948 hrs/mine34 fatalities
FY 202042 hrs/mine23 fatalities
FY 202139 hrs/mine39 fatalities
FY 202240 hrs/mine33 fatalities
FY 202341 hrs/mine41 fatalities
FY 202442 hrs/mine31 fatalities
FY 202541 hrs/mine28 fatalities

MSHA logged 48 total mining-area inspection hours per mine in FY2019, per MSHA's own fiscal-year data. By FY2025 that was 41 hours — a 15% decline, across a mine count that also shrank, from 13,105 to 12,568. Fatalities, to MSHA's credit, have not tracked the staffing line: FY2025 recorded 28 deaths across all mines, down from 31 in FY2024 and below every year since 2020 except one. That is the genuine complication in this story — the safety record has held, so far, on a shrinking enforcement base — which is exactly why FY2026, with coal production being pushed up by executive order and the agency's headcount still trending down, is the year that tests whether it keeps holding.

The takeaway

  • The money froze first. MSHA's appropriation has been exactly $387,816,000 for four consecutive fiscal years — FY2023 through the reported FY2026 enacted total — after Congress twice rejected a 10% cut.
  • The people kept leaving anyway. Authorized staffing fell from 2,152 positions in FY2017 to 1,656 in FY2025, a 23% drop that predates and outpaces the budget freeze, driven by attrition the agency says takes two years per hire to reverse.
  • The mandate is now pulling the other way. MSHA's own FY2026 request cites executive orders to expand coal production and mining broadly — more mines and more tonnage for a workforce funded to inspect fewer hours per mine than it did in 2019.

Budget and staffing figures are fiscal-year totals as published in the FY2026 Congressional Budget Justification; the FY2026 column reflects the administration's request, not an enacted breakdown, except where noted that Congress held the dollar total flat. Inspection-hours and fatality figures are MSHA's own fiscal-year tallies and will not match calendar-year counts reported elsewhere.

Sources

  • U.S. Department of Labor — FY2026 Congressional Budget Justification, MSHA volume: budget-by-activity breakdown, appropriation history (FY2017–FY2026), counts, and the agency's own citation of the executive orders driving coal expansion. dol.gov (mirror: web.archive.org)
  • MSHA — Mine Safety and Health At a Glance, fiscal-year edition issued Feb. 27, 2026 — inspection hours per mine, mine counts, and fatality counts, FY2019–FY2025. msha.gov
  • Jordan Barab, Confined Space — reporting on the enacted FY2026 Labor- omnibus confirming MSHA's budget held flat versus FY2025 after Congress rejected a proposed 10% cut. jordanbarab.com
  • Bloomberg Law — reporting on MSHA field-office closures, the offices still slated for closure, and the Beckley district's projected increase in oversight responsibility. news.bloomberglaw.com
  • Kentucky Lantern — reporting on the reversal of most of the more than 30 originally planned MSHA office closures. kentuckylantern.com
Weekly digest: the most-read systems, in brief. Mondays.

Comments

Always open. Logged-in readers can annotate paragraphs in place.

Loading comments…
or log in to comment under your account